What Should I Do About Billing Problems When Using HSA Money?

If you run into a billing problem or misunderstanding with a hospital or doctor's office for which you're planning to use money from your Health Savings Account (HSA), you could be in trouble.

This article will help you understand how hospital and doctor visits are different when paying with a Health Savings Account. Not better or worse, just different.

If you have an HSA, you must have health insurance. It's a requirement. However, if you are using money from your HSA, it means that you haven't hit the deductible of your policy yet.

In this particular situation, life is a bit different when it comes to resolving billing disputes with hospitals.

Insurance companies have a comprehensive system for dealing with billing disputes when they have covered a hospital stay or doctor visit. But when they haven't covered it because you are still within your deductible, that comprehensive dispute resolution system doesn't necessarily apply.

Here are some points to keep in mind when you are dealing with a hospital in a billing dispute, and you have paid with HSA money. I learned these important points when I was talking to an expert in this field named Dr. Vincent Riccardi, who is the owner of American Medical Consumer (www.medconsumer.com), a company dedicated to helping people resolve billing disputes with hospitals and doctors.

Here's what Dr. Riccardi has to say:

  • First, discuss the issue with your physician. Sometimes the problem stems from an incorrectly applied billing code and the doctor can easily change it to please the hospital and resolve the problem on the spot.
  • Negotiate in person. Especially if you just don't have the money to pay a bill, it makes the best sense to negotiate face-to-face with the person at the hospital who has the authority to reverse or reduce the charges. Hospitals would often rather be paid part of a bill than risk losing the entire bill. Be honest and forthright and you may have a good chance in negotiating a reduced fee from the hospital. This includes the situations where it was a misunderstanding on your part. It's at least worth a try.
  • Don't bother going to the State Medical Board. In most cases, they are not able to help you. This is the case with most government agencies. Even the Departments of Insurance cannot help, because this isn't an insurance problem, it is technically a fee-for-service situation.
  • Recourse to a lawyer is usually not fruitful unless there is a big amount involved. For amounts less than $5,000 (which is what most HSA-style deductibles are), a lawyer probably won't be able to help you.
  • Remember that the only things that count in negotiations like this are the things that have been written down. If a doctor mentioned something to you but didn't write it down, it probably won't help you. Get things in writing all the way through the process.
  • I think of HSAs as a way to "be your own insurance company" for the small stuff (under your deductible). That is its power. But it also means that when it comes to disputes, you also have to "be your own insurance company" and take charge of the negotiations with the hospital, just like an insurance company would. Your willingness and ability to negotiate will influence your ability to get unfair charges reversed or, at least, lessened. But it's a "do it yourself" situation, so be aware of that when you sign up for an HSA.

    Daryl Kulak is the author of the book "Health Insurance Off the Grid - A Wonderful Way to Use Alternative Medicine and Save Money on Insurance Using the New Health Savings Account (HSA)."

    The book provides a nine-step plan to get your self-employed or small business health insurance costs under control using a unique approach you won't find anywhere else. The book is available for sale as an e-Book or paperback at the Website http://www.healthoffthegrid.com

    Latest News


    Deal-Seeking Travelers Should Not Overlook Need for Travel Insurance
    MarketWatch - 2 hours ago
    Although travelers are seeking deals and jumping on last-minute travel offers, Travel Guard reminds consumers that travel insurance remains essential no ...
    From Homeowner to Renter: What You Need to Know About Renter's ... MarketWatch
    all 17 news articles

    WWL

    21st Century Holding Company's Subsidiary Federated National ...
    MarketWatch - 1 hour ago
    an insurance holding company, today announced that it received approval from the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation (OIR) to take out (assume) up to ...
    La. grand jury indicts former head of state-run insurance concern USA Today
    Ex-CEO of Citizens Property Insurance indicted 2TheAdvocate
    Former chief of Citizens Insurance indicted WBXH
    WWL - KATC
    all 14 news articles

    dBTechno

    Insurers propose universal, centralized healthcare
    Los Angeles Times, CA - 12 hours ago
    Several consumer groups criticize the early bid by America's Health Insurance Plans, a trade group that fought an overhaul in the 1990s, to take an active ...
    Medicine for the Job Market New York Times
    Health Insurance Trade Group Proposal Praised By Sen Kennedy CNNMoney.com
    Nurses Reject AHIP Proposal as a 'Marshall Plan for Health Insurers' MarketWatch
    Boston Globe - Wall Street Journal
    all 213 news articles

    Electric Insurance Appoints Sweet & Sons, Inc.
    MarketWatch - 7 hours ago
    "When looking for a new relationship with an agency, Electric Insurance seeks agencies that have track records of delighting customers," said Michael J. ...

    White & Case Recruits Top Bank, Insurance Regulatory Lawyer
    MarketWatch - 4 hours ago
    NEW YORK, Dec 04, 2008 /PRNewswire via COMTEX/ -- Global law firm White & Case LLP is expanding its firmwide Bank and Insurance Regulatory Practice with the ...

    American Family Insurance Selected as Recipient of 2008 E-Fusion Award
    MarketWatch - 1 hour ago
    OLDWICK, NJ, Dec 04, 2008 (BUSINESS WIRE) -- American Family Insurance's Teen Safe Driver Program, which uses a mobile video and online notification system ...

    AARP’s Stealth Fees Often Sting Seniors With Costlier Insurance
    Bloomberg - 11 hours ago
    He signed up for an auto insurance policy endorsed by AARP, believing the advertising that said he would save money. He didn’t. ...
    Health Insurance, Business Lobbyists Join Discussions About ... Medical News Today (press release)
    all 3 news articles

    CSC Announces Social Networking Community for Property and ...
    MarketWatch - 3 hours ago
    today announced the latest innovation in the evolution of its property and casualty (P&C) insurance client community: the introduction of WikonnecT, ...

    ABC News

    Bernanke says home price insurance would be costly
    Reuters - 3 hours ago
    WASHINGTON, Dec 4 (Reuters) - An idea floated by some economists to encourage home buyers to purchase home price insurance would be costly in the current ...
    Bernanke calls for measures to stem foreclosures International Herald Tribune
    US Fed demands foreclosures push BBC News
    Bernanke Says US Must Step Up Foreclosure Efforts (Update1) Bloomberg
    Motley Fool - Austin American-Statesman
    all 1,102 news articles

    IBC Insurance buys up InsCorp
    Bizjournals.com, NC - 4 hours ago
    The purchase of the company expands IBC Insurance’s presence in Laredo and increases the growth that it is seeing in all markets and business segments. ...

    Resources