A Secret Revealed: Why Most (Day) Traders Fail

The following perspective on (day) trading comes from my many years of experience of active day trading or being the moderator of one of the largest day trading chat rooms on the Internet.

One of the biggest problems I see with new traders (and even some old ones) has nothing to do with the software or the broker they are using. Nor is the problem a result of buying too high or selling to low; or not having enough money. The problem isn't any of those things.

It has to do with not having a trading plan. A good trading plan will go a long way towards solving the problems mentioned above.

Ted Williams was once asked how he hit the baseball so much better then everyone else. He said he had no idea and that he just went up to the plate and swung at the ball. There has only been one Ted Williams and as great as he was at hitting a baseball, I don't think he would have made a great day trader with that approach. Most great hitters have an idea what they are going to do every time they step up to the plate. Traders need to know exactly what they expect every time they enter a trade.

Everyone should start out with a basic trading plan and use it. As the old saying goes, "Plan your work and work your plan". However, you also have to be ready to be flexible. That has to be part of your planning. As Clint Eastwood said as his character in "Heartbreak Ridge", "You got to adjust, you got to learn to improvise. And if all else fails, you to learn to survive!" Traders that are not able to make adjustments, improvise and survive will experience their own Heartbreak Ridge.

Your trading plan can't be one where you simply figure you are just going to follow someone else. That may be one way to get a start and a bit of experience, and it can be a part of a much bigger overall plan. But it cannot start and end there. You have to learn to trade on your own so you don't accidentally follow someone off a cliff. You have to know who to follow and who not to follow.

When I was trading I made a lot of good trades knowing who to follow and who not to follow. Yet, in the long run, I do not believe you can make a living doing that. The biggest problem in following other traders is being too far behind the trade because you are "following" and not leading. I think each and every trader has to become the very best trader he can possibly be, on his own. He needs to get there as fast as he can. Following more experienced traders can be a means to this end and can help get you started, but it cannot be the end. This takes planning.

A basic trading plan will take in your long-term goals and objectives as a trader. You'll have to decide if you want to try to make a career out of trading, or just be a part time trader. Once you have decided this you can make other decisions such as how much money you would like to make at either full time or part time trading. Your money goals have to be realistic. They can't just be, "I want to make as much money as I can". These basic decisions will determine the time and money you will have to commit.

Your trading plan should be on going, constantly evolving and eventually contain things like how many days, weeks, and hours you will need to trade to meet your goals. If it is as detailed as I think it should be, you would know how many trades per day and how much profit per trade you will have to average. Of course, these things will have to be developed over time and added to your plan as you go and as you gain more knowledge.

There are many excellent books on learning to day trade. My favorites are found at http://www.TraderAide.com/books

No permission is needed to reproduce an unedited copy of this article as long the About The Author tag is left in tact and included. We do request that we be informed of where it is posted and reciprocal links will be considered. Email floyd@sbmag.org.

Floyd Snyder has been trading and investing in the stock market for three decades. He was on the forefront of the day trading craze that swept nation back in late 1990's both as a trader and later as the moderator of one of the Internet's largest real time trading rooms.

Floyd is also the owner of http://www.TraderAide.com, Strictly Business Magazine at http://www.sbmag.org, FrameHouseGallery.com and EducationResourcesNetwork.com

Latest News


Telegraph.co.uk

CIC Head Wary of Investing in Western Banks
Wall Street Journal - Dec 2, 2008
Lou Jiwei, who head's China Investment Corp., said the uncertainty surrounding Western banks and the policy decisions that may determine their fate makes it ...
CIC weary of Western banks Thomson Merger News (registration)
China's sovereign wealth fund to avoid western financial firms: report AFP
CIC Now Very Wary of Investment in Foreign Financial Firms ChinaStakes.com
Reuters - In-Forum
all 270 news articles

Dividend Investing for Monthly Income
Seeking Alpha, NY - 5 hours ago
After you have selected the dividend growth stocks that fit your selection criteria, it is time to research their payment dates. Most dividend investors try ...

Is Real Estate Investing Our Best Shot at Wealth?
Seeking Alpha, NY - 9 hours ago
91 percent of homeowners surveyed by real-estate-services firm Realogy Corp. thought that owning a home was the best long-term investment they could make, ...

ETF Investing: 5 Pitfalls to Avoid
U.S. News & World Report, DC - 21 hours ago
By Kirk Shinkle Security, transparency, low costs: It's the mantra of the exchange-traded fund industry, and by and large, most ETFs do live up to the ...
Invesco PowerShares Announces Zero Capital Gains Distributions for ... MarketWatch
Managing a Portfolio in a Bear Market Seeking Alpha
Building a Portfolio Using ETFs U.S. News & World Report
all 16 news articles

Calgary Herald

Global Investing Roundups
Money Morning - 12 hours ago
The world’s biggest nuclear utility company, Electricité de France SA will offer as much as $6.5 billion for assets of Constellation Energy Group, ...
Delayed quote data MarketWatch
all 698 news articles

Criterion Investments Scoops Canadian Investment Marketing Award ...
MarketWatch - 4 hours ago
The same applies to investing in long-term growth themes, and Criterion built the case for why now is time to get ahead of the curve by investing in water ...
Making a bet in a free-fall market BusinessWorld Online
all 10 news articles

PureWave Networks Completes a $12 Million Series B Funding Round
MarketWatch - 2 hours ago
The firm consists of experienced individuals with extensive operating and investing experience, and takes an active role in helping its portfolio companies ...

Ziegler Exchange Traded Trust Announces Change to Previously ...
MarketWatch - Dec 3, 2008
Prospective purchasers of the NYSE Arca Tech 100 ETF should consider the investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses carefully before investing. ...

Maktoob Business (press release)

Recessions Are Perfect for Currency Investing
Seeking Alpha, NY - Dec 3, 2008
One thing that I love about the currency market is that there is always a currency or two going up at all times, even when stocks and commodities are ...
God Bless America, Land of Free Lunch Smartmoney.com
Yen Gains on Concern Recession Will Spur Repatriation of Funds Bloomberg
all 679 news articles

Washington Post

Fidelity to Roll out New Home Page Providing Real-Time Financial ...
MarketWatch - 7 hours ago
"Investors today need timely and reliable financial information to make smart investing decisions, especially in times of market and economic uncertainty," ...
Online Money: Fidelity expands online news focus The Associated Press
all 104 news articles

Resources