Industry Regulation and Recent Legislation

A number of states from coast to coast are attempting to impose further regulations on the payday loan industry, but without much success in many cases. Consumers of payday loans have generally argued against more stringent measures and limitations, that would limit their access to payday loans. And, in the meantime, the payday loan industry continues to grow, both in the numbers of loans issued and the dollar amounts of loans issued.

In Washington State, there were no less than 14 bills introduced during the 2004-2005 legislative session, with the specific intent of more tightly regulating the payday loan industry. Nine of the most aggressive proposals stalled in committee. If passed, these bills would have lowered payday loan interest rates and decreased the maximum amounts that a borrower could access.

Even more heavily opposed was a proposal to establish a statewide database of payday loans, giving both the industry and the state a way of looking at how many payday loans a borrower already had when he or she applied for another. This measure was designed to prevent borrowers from seeking loans from multiple lenders. Some analysts viewed the proposal as a potentially dangerous intrusion into people's personal finances. The payday loan industry contended that cutting interest rates and putting a lower cap on loan amounts would significantly damage their business.

Most of the regulations proposed in Washington were stalled in legislative committees and never reached the floor of the legislature.

A bill passed two years ago in Washington already provided a number of consumer protections. The state requires, for example, that borrowers have the right to cancel a loan within one business day. A borrower 'payment plan' was also made mandatory, requiring that once a borrower has received four loans from the same lender, he or she is allowed to work out a repayment plan over at least 60 days.

The State of Oregon has also been embroiled in a payday loan controversy including attempts to restrict an industry that is largely unregulated in that state. A bill proposed during the 2004-2005 legislative session would have imposed mandatory 31 day loan periods, effectively eliminating the practice of rollovers.

More than 1500 clients of just one payday lender wrote urging the Oregon legislature not to pass the proposed restrictions. In general, those individuals said they valued being able to access short term loans quickly and easily, without having to depend on the good will of family or friends when they ran into an emergency cash flow situation. They also indicated that they did not consider the interest rates unfair.

At the same time, the dollar amount of payday loans granted in Oregon has grown by 285 percent in the past five years, and the number of loans issued has grown 138 percent in the same time period.

In New Mexico, the State House of Representatives introduced a bill that would limit payday loans to $1,000 each and imposed restrictions on some fees and charges. While the legislation did not prevent rollovers, it specified that a loan was forgiven once the customer had paid twice the amount that was originally borrowed. Consumer groups and the state's Attorney General pushed for a payday loan interest cap. Arizona's governor has stated that he will not sign the measure because it fails to provide adequate protection for borrowers.

On the other side of the U.S., in the State of Maine, lawmakers have been asked to approve changes to existing laws that would allow significant expansion of the payday loan industry. Under current state law, fees are capped at $15 for loans up to $250, and at $25 for loans exceeding $250. One of the proposed changes in that state would allow lenders to charge as much as 17.5% per week, which would amount to $17.50 per $100.

In addition, payday lenders in Maine would be exempted from the state's existing consumer credit code. They would be allowed to use advertising methods that are currently prohibited and to have greater leeway in collection methods in the event of default.

The U.S. Military contends that military personnel are disproportionately targeted by payday loan companies and that lenders adjacent to military bases charge higher rates of interest. A recent study lends some validity to that point of view.

Most of the recent legislation aimed at regulating payday loans across the country, however, is aimed at in-state, storefront businesses, rather than Internet based lenders. It may be that Internet payday lenders have not been targeted as aggressively because they tend to be much more competitive, offering lower interest rates and lengthier repayment terms.

Ethan Hunter is the author of many credit related articles. If you are looking for help with Payday Loans or any type of credit issue please visit us at http://www.PaydayLoanChoice.com

Latest News


The Star-Ledger - NJ.com

General Growth gets 2-week reprieve on loans
Chicago Tribune, United States - 1 hour ago
The real estate investment trust said it and the syndicate of lenders "are continuing their discussions" on a longer-term extension to the loan, ...
GGP Gains Two-Week Extension on $900M Loans GlobeSt. com
General Growth gets 2-week extension on $900 million in loans Chicago Daily Herald
General Growth Properties gets loan extension Bizjournals.com
The Associated Press - Reuters
all 121 news articles

Wall Street Journal Blogs

Restoring the flow of credit to entrepreneurs
Los Angeles Times, CA - 10 hours ago
A Treasury Department program aims to make it easier for lenders to find buyers for the loans they make. By Cyndia Zwahlen The credit crunch looks like an ...
Forbes: Let the Small Business Administration work Austin American-Statesman
SBA Applauds Treasury Action to Bolster Secondary Market for Small ... MarketWatch
Feds hope to unfreeze SBA, consumer lending Bizjournals.com
Wisconsin State Journal - FOXBusiness
all 123 news articles

Straits Times

Government plans new credit, mortgage programs
O Jornal, MA - 31 minutes ago
The Fed program for consumer debt will lend up to $200 billion to the holders of securities backed by various types of consumer loans such as credit cards, ...
Lenders Become Proactive New York Times
Mortgage relief gets stuck Cape Cod Times
Partisan blame for financial crisis not so easily affixed Las Vegas Sun
TheStreet.com - Washington Post
all 2,138 news articles

New York Times

Turning Around the Idea of Student Loans
New York Times, United States - 11 hours ago
“This is a five-year loan, and that helps ensure a certain amount of longevity for this project.” Justin said he first became interested in poverty issues ...

Ottawa Citizen

The Fed boosted emergency loans to banks and firms
The Associated Press - Nov 28, 2008
The report also said investment firms borrowed an average of $52.4 billion from the Fed's emergency loan program over the week ending Wednesday, ...
Fed Commercial Paper Holdings Rise to $295.1 Billion (Update2) Bloomberg
Bailout Report Card--A Failing Grade and a Frightening Outlook for ... The Cutting Edge
"Oops, We Meant $7 TRILLION!" What Hank and Ben Are Up to and How ... OpEdNews
Examiner.com - CNNMoney.com
all 454 news articles

Student debt levels portend rising loan default rates
Indianapolis Star, United States - 8 hours ago
They were aiming to win big so they could pay off their student loans. "If you don't try, you can't win," said Brown, a 26-year-old marketing consultant. ...

Hedge Fund Manager Hendry Bets on Deflation With UK War Loans
Bloomberg - 2 hours ago
The “Jolly Long Bond,” as Hendry calls the war loan, will be the most reactive to deflation because not having a maturity means it has long duration, ...

Loss of college loans lender may have little effect
Spartanburg Herald Journal (subscription), SC - 3 hours ago
The financial aid director for Spartanburg Community College stressed that these types of supplemental loans are separate from the Stafford Federal Student ...

Detroit's Big 3 Will Try Again To Get Federal Loans
NPR - 4 hours ago
They're going to try, again, to convince Congress to give them federal loans. They say they need the money to avoid an industry collapse. ...

Boston Globe

Problem-solver
Boston Globe, United States - 8 hours ago
Bair's plan to systematically modify 2.2 million loans for defaulting borrowers has drawn widespread support - except from the Bush White House. ...
Avoiding your own mortgage collapse The News Journal
Efforts are under way to head off foreclosure Philadelphia Inquirer
all 4 news articles

Resources