Should You Ever Take a Payday Loan?

Payday loans have many names -- cash advances, signature loans and paycheck loans, etc. Payday lenders provide quick and easy short-term cash to those who need money immediately. That's the big reason why they're so popular.

However, payday loans come at exorbitant costs. This can -- and often does -- lead borrowers into a downward spiral of rapidly escalating debt. Let's look at the issue from various angles to get a complete picture.

First, the pluses. Here's why cash advances may hold enormous appeal for you.

• You can have bad credit and still qualify for a payday loan. In most cases, no credit check is conducted.
• The process is fast -- it takes as little as 20 minutes to complete. You can even find lenders who target approvals in 30 seconds!
• There are no upfront costs -- so the buy-now-pay-later mentality can find full expression.
• You can apply in person at a local outlet, over the phone or over the Internet.
• You get funds deposited into your bank account in 24 hours.
• Compared to some other sources for cash, payday loans are discreet -- no one else needs to know about it.
• The transactions are secure -- your financial information remains private.

If you're faced with an emergency -- say, unexpected medical bills -- your only consideration might be to get money now. The speed and convenience of a cash advance comes in handy here.

So what are the disadvantages?

The most obvious one -- high costs. A payday loan can cost you say, $15 per two weeks. If you're borrowing only for two weeks, that doesn't sound like much. However, if you calculate the Annual Percentage Rate (APR), you'll see it comes to 391%!

If you don't think that's too much, let me ask you this question. If you invested money in the stock market, what would you consider a good annual rate of return? 20%? Maybe 30%? If you made a 20% return (on average) in stocks year after year, you'd be doing very well indeed. And this is for an investment that's generally considered high risk.

Now compare that with what the payday loan companies charge. You are providing them with a return on their money they likely won't get anywhere else on the planet!

There is another, less obvious reason why payday loans are dangerous. According to some estimates, over 60% of borrowers roll over a payday loan. Many take loans repeatedly, too.

Let's put in some numbers so that you can clearly see what rollovers imply.

Assume you borrow $400 for two weeks at a cost of $15 per $100 per two weeks. At the end of two weeks, you owe them a total of $460.

Let's say you don't repay the $400 at the end of two weeks. Instead, you request a rollover. So you pay them the lending fee of $60 and they agree to roll over the loan for another two weeks. The total cost of the loan at the end of 4 weeks may be as follows:

Original loan amount: $400
Fresh lending fees payable: $60
Late fees payable: $60 (assuming late fees apply at the same rate as lending fees)
Lending fees already paid: $60
Total: $580

At the end of this period (which is 4 weeks from the day you originally took the loan), you decide that you don't have $580 available and so request them to roll the loan over for another two weeks. Then this is what it can cost you in total at the end of 6 weeks:

Original loan amount: $400
Fresh lending fees payable: $60
Late fees payable: $60
Lending fees already paid: $120
Late fees already paid: $60
Total: $700

If you continue this process for six months (more specifically, for 24 weeks), this is what it may cost you in total:

Original loan amount: $400
Fresh lending fees payable: $60
Late fees payable: $60
Lending fees already paid: $660
Late fees already paid: $600
Total: $1780

For an original loan of $400, in a mere 6 months, the payday loan company will collect fees and charges of $1380 from you. That's 3.45 times the amount you borrowed. In APR terms that's 749.5%! If over 60% of borrowers roll over their loans, no wonder many payday loan companies are wildly profitable!

Snowballing costs can easily lead you into a debt trap if you get addicted to payday loans.

So what are the key points to keep in mind when dealing with payday loan companies? Two things:

First, avoid them if at all possible. The best way is, of course, to get your finances fully under control so that you always have cash and / or credit available to meet emergencies.

Second, if you do choose to borrow from payday loan companies, borrow only an amount you're 100% sure you can repay on the due date. If that amount is too low to meet your needs, get additional funding from other sources. Because rolling over cash advances is one of the worst things you can do to yourself.

About the Author

Prakash Menon is a financial expert and writer specializing in managing personal debt and providing wealth building solutions. He has written articles on cash advances, personal debt management and other topics.

Latest News

Washington Post

US Rethinks Roles of Fannie, Freddie Wall Street Journal - 11 hours ago The main focus is on the government-backed buyers of home loans: Fannie Mae, created in 1938, and its younger cousin, Freddie Mac, formed in 1970. ... Government plans new credit, mortgage programs O Jornal Lenders Become Proactive New York Times Mortgage relief gets stuck Cape Cod Times Las Vegas Sun - TheStreet.com all 2,140 news articles

The Star-Ledger - NJ.com

General Growth gets 2-week reprieve on loans Chicago Tribune, United States - 2 hours ago The real estate investment trust said it and the syndicate of lenders "are continuing their discussions" on a longer-term extension to the loan, ... GGP Gains Two-Week Extension on $900M Loans GlobeSt. com General Growth gets 2-week extension on $900 million in loans Chicago Daily Herald General Growth Properties gets loan reprieve The Associated Press Reuters - RTT News all 121 news articles

Wall Street Journal Blogs

Restoring the flow of credit to entrepreneurs Los Angeles Times, CA - 10 hours ago A Treasury Department program aims to make it easier for lenders to find buyers for the loans they make. By Cyndia Zwahlen The credit crunch looks like an ... Forbes: Let the Small Business Administration work Austin American-Statesman SBA Applauds Treasury Action to Bolster Secondary Market for Small ... MarketWatch Feds hope to unfreeze SBA, consumer lending Bizjournals.com Wisconsin State Journal - FOXBusiness all 123 news articles

findingDulcinea

Can the Federal Government Save the Student Loan Market? findingDulcinea, New York - 27 minutes ago by Anne Szustek The Federal Reserve recently announced a $200 billion lending facility for private student loan lenders. Is this the best way to make higher ... The Fed boosted emergency loans to banks and firms The Associated Press Fed Commercial Paper Holdings Rise to $295.1 Billion (Update2) Bloomberg "Oops, We Meant $7 TRILLION!" What Hank and Ben Are Up to and How ... OpEdNews The Cutting Edge - Examiner.com all 455 news articles

New York Times

Turning Around the Idea of Student Loans New York Times, United States - 11 hours ago “This is a five-year loan, and that helps ensure a certain amount of longevity for this project.” Justin said he first became interested in poverty issues ...

Student debt levels portend rising loan default rates Indianapolis Star, United States - 8 hours ago They were aiming to win big so they could pay off their student loans. "If you don't try, you can't win," said Brown, a 26-year-old marketing consultant. ...

Hedge Fund Manager Hendry Bets on Deflation With UK War Loans Bloomberg - 3 hours ago The “Jolly Long Bond,” as Hendry calls the war loan, will be the most reactive to deflation because not having a maturity means it has long duration, ...

Loss of college loans lender may have little effect Spartanburg Herald Journal (subscription), SC - 3 hours ago The financial aid director for Spartanburg Community College stressed that these types of supplemental loans are separate from the Stafford Federal Student ...

Detroit's Big 3 Will Try Again To Get Federal Loans NPR - 4 hours ago They're going to try, again, to convince Congress to give them federal loans. They say they need the money to avoid an industry collapse. ...

Boston Globe

Problem-solver Boston Globe, United States - 8 hours ago Bair's plan to systematically modify 2.2 million loans for defaulting borrowers has drawn widespread support - except from the Bush White House. ... Avoiding your own mortgage collapse The News Journal Efforts are under way to head off foreclosure Philadelphia Inquirer all 4 news articles