The Permissive Environment is the Suspect

The permissive and participatory conduct which most employees take for granted, eventually escalates into the more serious assaultive behavior commonly referred to as employee on employee workplace violence starts with innuendos, a bad word, or simple jokes taken out of context or used to inflame another. Initiation of a proper and thorough investigation is possible under the auspices of a Threat Assessment Team. Banter between employees if left alone by supervisors becomes tense and often results in a more aggressive response. The truth of the matter is that in most cases this banter is perceived as harmless shop talk.

Supervisors often believe that this healthy shop talk builds camaraderie and does not detract from performance. However, such permissive behavior empowers the potential perpetrator who may feel he enjoys the partiality of the supervisor. After all, he does his job, pumps out the numbers and meets the "bosses" demands. Regardless of the relationship and his performance, definite and clear action should be taken initially to curtail the potential of an explosive situation from impacting the workplace. The spontaneous reaction by the victim although surprising could be sufficiently volatile to affect bystanders as well.

Remembering that the business owner is ultimately responsible for the actions they fail to take in any situation places the decision in question. The prevention of workplace violence requires a proactive response. Security is everyone's responsibility but ultimately management's duty. The exposure to violent behavior by non employees is yet another issue which will be presented in future articles.

In a permissive environment, the uninformed employee has no idea that emotions tied into simple acts of harassment are an explosive combination often leading to a spontaneous counter response by the victim. While the response is unfortunate in terms of who ultimately precipitated the incident, the victim who is now taking the action into his hands becomes the aggressor and must be held accountable.

Using a Threat Assessment Team or a trained group of individuals would be the proper approach in this scenario and in future incidents. The conduct of the Threat Assessment Process would involve the total analysis of information and intelligence available about the participants, the incident and the environment in order to render a fair and impartial outcome. Being properly trained is key. Knowledge of how to conduct a fact finding investigation is critical to the successful determination of the type of disciplinary action or criminal prosecution it might bring. The process should be synchronized and well coordinated and reflective of the organization's leadership team, if possible to insure that the preliminary responsibility of conducting the fact finding investigative process does not fall on the shoulder's of the Security Director long after the fact. The major players of the Threat Assessment Team might include at a minimum: the Immediate Supervisor, Personnel & Human Resource Managers, Employee Assistance, Safety and Security Managers to insure a thorough Threat Assessment (Investigation) is conducted.

In Assessing the above scenario the root cause of the confrontation was the unabated name calling, verbal abuse and innuendos, created by a permissive and improperly supervised environment. Supervisors who fail to step in to correct this type of behavior can be held civilly liable and responsible for their failure to act early or appropriately to prevent escalation or confrontations. In cases of death or serious injury between employees or customers, wrongful death law suits are often filed in addition to criminal prosecution. Not knowing is no longer a legitimate excuse.

When supervisors fail to act appropriately, management has the burden of investigating the incident, dealing with the issue of the aggressor over the contributory behavior of the instigator and decide on the appropriate progressive disciplinary actions (or if necessary, referral to local police for prosecution).

And, so while a Zero Tolerance Policy is necessary and highly recommended, it should not be an absolute standard in administering discipline until the "root cause" of the contributory behavior becomes clear through the Assessment Process. When controlling or addressing the potential fruits of unwelcome behavior or to more appropriately, prevent incidents dealing with a Workplace Security Issue, every situation should not be resolved in the same manner with the same administrative decision. Any broad-brush approach to enforcing the Zero Tolerance Policy sours the innocent bystanders and prejudices the potential witnesses who may fear retaliation or retribution, factors which may further complicate the disciplinary process and/or criminal referral.

Felix P. Nater is President of Nater Associates, Ltd. a security management consulting firm specializing in workplace security and workplace violence prevention. He retired as a U. S. Postal Inspector in 2001 with over 30 years of criminal and security experience. The last two years have been spent consulting to small to midsize companies on security related issues affecting the workplace. He has a FREE on-line newsletter entitled "Workplace Violence Crime Prevention and Security Awareness which you can subscribe to through his website at http://www.naterassociates.com.

Latest News

Washington Post

Wal-Mart disappoints analysts, Walgreen chops management team Bizjournals.com, NC - 7 hours ago (NYSE:WAG) announced plans to offer early retirement and severance programs to some 1000 corporate and field management employees, or 9 percent of those ... AP Business NewsBrief at 11:14 am EST TMCnet all 1,885 news articles

Comcast Network Management Policies In Place PC Magazine - 18 hours ago Comcast has fulfilled its pledge to put in a place a protocol agnostic network management policy by year's end, according to filings with the Federal ... Comcast Removes Blocks On File Sharing InformationWeek all 6 news articles

Paragon Wealth Management Offers Free Portfolio Reviews MSNBC - 9 hours ago PROVO, UT - Paragon Wealth Management is offering free portfolio reviews to investors to help them know where to allocate their portfolios in 2009. ...

Saratoga Electronic Solutions Inc. Announces Revocation of ... FOXBusiness - 6 hours ago ... issued Management Cease Trade Order which prohibited trading by directors, officers and certain employees of Saratoga in the securities of Saratoga. ...

WELT ONLINE

Gary Berntsen Thinks CIA Needs 'Leadership Not Management' FOXNews - Jan 7, 2009 CIA COVERT OFFICER : Actually, we need leadership, not management at CIA. That person who's going to be in charge of CIA is in charge of our fight, ... Video: Analyst Weighs in on Obama's CIA Pick AssociatedPress Obama's intel picks short on direct experience The Associated Press Obama Is Under Fire Over Panetta Selection Washington Post GovExec.com - Wall Street Journal all 2,461 news articles

New York Times

Microsoft Touts Power Management in Windows 7 ENT News - 1 hour ago Improved power management got briefly mentioned among the expected benefits of Windows 7 on Wednesday at the Consumer Electronics Show. ... Hacking Windows 7 beta problems Computerworld Windows Live Essentials released Neowin Microsoft releases Windows Server 2008 R2 beta VNUNet.com all 1,213 news articles

Babcock Lenders Favor Plans to Retain Management, Review Says Bloomberg - 5 hours ago 9 (Bloomberg) -- Babcock & Brown Ltd.’s lenders favor plans that will keep management in place to oversee the sale of the company’s assets, the Australian ...

Seven Ways to Reduce IT Costs Using Master Data Management eWeek,  NY - 48 minutes ago Master Data Management (MDM) software and services are designed specifically for this purpose. An MDM platform offers a consolidated view of a company's ...

Hedge Funds Lost Record 18.3% on Misjudged Markets Bloomberg - 1 hour ago Firms such as Dwight Anderson’s Ospraie Management LLC and Jeffrey Gendell’s Tontine Associates LLC closed funds, while Paul Tudor Jones’s Tudor Investment ... Picton Mahoney Announces Domestic Hedge Fund Offerings Open to New ... Canada NewsWire (press release) all 53 news articles

Tensoft(R) Announces Three Revenue Cycle Management Products for ... MSNBC - 13 hours ago Each of the three solutions is designed for companies with specific, challenging revenue management needs. All three versions improve the efficiency and ...