Problem Solving the Problem Solving Meeting

We go to meetings to share information, to report on project status, to make decisions, to get the free lunch, and because we were invited. (Sorry that I digressed). This is only a partial list - there are many other valid reasons for holding meetings.

Perhaps the most common and best reason for a meeting though is to solve a problem. A meeting is a great place to do this - you get a variety of people with a variety of experiences, knowledge and perspectives together to ensure that the best possible solution is identified and that all of the important considerations have been taken into account.

The problem is, that while the venue and the people might be correct, often the process is flawed. It is flawed because one question hasn't clearly been asked and answered.

The Typical Situation

Have you ever been in a meeting where 20 minutes (or an hour or more) into the discussion of the problem, people start to realize that they aren't all working on exactly the same problem, or are already assuming certain solutions? Most people I have asked this question of over the years have nodded in the affirmative. It is that this moment that a meeting must stop - and clarification must begin.

It is also in these moments where frustration builds, rework begins, and meetings get a bad reputation.

The solution to this situation is to ask and answer the one question.

The Problem Solving Question

That question is: "What is the problem?"

It seems so simple. I mean, why would anyone ever start problem solving without truly knowing what the problem is? People don't do it on purpose, of course, they do it because:

- The problem is clear in their mind (or at least they think so).

- They assume everyone knows the problem exists.

- They assume everyone agrees that it is, in fact, a problem.

Unfortunately these reasons prevail too often.

So, what is the problem?

Getting a group agreement and understanding of the problem is one of best things you can do to improve the speed and effectiveness of group problem solving. But how do you do it?

The Problem Statement

You do it with a clear concise, well written problem statement.

A problem statement succinctly defines what the problem is. It is written to produce clarity of thought and to reduce the assumptions people make regarding the problem. At least as important as these reasons, a good problem statement keeps us from assuming a solution, before we even state the problem.

In academic circles, problem statements are often long (one or more pages), detailed (complete with lots of data and statistics) narratives. This is not what we need in a meeting. What we need is a short one or two sentence description of

- what the problem is

- who it affects

- when is it a problem

- where it is a problem

Your problem statement should not answer the "why?" question - as your problem solving process should lead you to a clear understanding of "why?" Remember the goal is to define the problem so that everyone agrees to the problem and its scope.

Some Examples

While the format may vary, here are a couple of example problem statements to help you get started:

- We (our team) don't have timely data to determine when to make the switch from "X' to "Y".

- Our turnaround time at the Madison facility is currently two weeks, which puts us at a competitive disadvantage compared to our competitors.

- Our enrollments for the summer program are 20% behind last year and 30% behind projections.

The final format of this statement matters less than making sure that it answers the questions above. Sometimes people state the new desired result in the problem statement as well (e.g. "currently the process takes four days and the desired time is two days"). This can be a valuable addition if this end goal is already known. Often at this stage we don't have enough information to know just how much improvement we can achieve.

A problem well stated is a problem half solved. By taking the time needed to gain agreement on a clear definition of your problem before starting the problem solving process, you truly have reduced the total time for your problem solving efforts drastically. This effort and discipline will improve your results noticeably, and immediately.

Kevin Eikenberry is a leadership expert and the Chief Potential Officer of The Kevin Eikenberry Group (http://KevinEikenberry.com), a learning consulting company. To receive a free Special Report on leadership that includes resources, ideas, and advice go to http://www.kevineikenberry.com/leadership.asp or call us at (317) 387-1424 or 888.LEARNER.

Latest News


Single Source Introduces New Advanced Quote Management (AQM)(TM ...
MarketWatch - 11 hours ago
All functions seamlessly integrate to the inherent back-office financials, inventory, purchasing and management reporting functionality of SM-Plus-meeting ...
KANA Recognized by Leading Industry Publications for Innovation ... Business Wire (press release)
all 22 news articles

BBC News

ECONOMIC REPORT Global manufacturing gauges collapse in November
MarketWatch - 9 hours ago
... of price pressures hit an all-time low, according to a survey of corporate purchasing managers released Monday by the Institute for Supply Management. ...
Manufacturing index drops to 26-year low Washington Post
Manufacturing index at 26-year low CNNMoney.com
Manufacturing hits 26-year low Bizjournals.com
CNN - Forbes
all 619 news articles

HispanicBusiness.com

Construction Spending Reflects Economic Slowdown
New York Times, United States - 4 hours ago
The Institute for Supply Management’s monthly index of manufacturing activity fell to 36.2, from October’s 38.9. The reading is worse than Wall Street ...
October construction spending drops 1.2 percent International Herald Tribune
US manufacturing weakest since 1982 The Australian
Construction spending fell again in October Bizjournals.com
guardian.co.uk - International Herald Tribune
all 269 news articles

WCBD

Price Tags on Partridges and Pear Trees: A Different CPI
New York Times, United States - 4 hours ago
By Catherine Rampell For the last 24 years, PNC Wealth Management (or its predecessor, Provident Bank) has released this whimsical index, a measure of the ...
Video: 12 Days of Christmas' Items Would Cost $86,609 AssociatedPress
'12 Days of Christmas' items would cost $86609 The Associated Press
Twelve Days of Christmas would cost $21000 Telegraph.co.uk
Reuters - guardian.co.uk
all 351 news articles

AGC and LCM Declare Dividends
MarketWatch - 4 hours ago
a diversified closed-end management investment company, has declared its December monthly dividend of $0.0664 per share, reflecting a reduction of $0.0286 ...
AGC and LCM Declare Dividends Trading Markets (press release)
Madison Strategic Sector Premium Fund (MSP) Declares Quarterly ... MarketWatch
PPR - $.0340 November Dividend MarketWatch
MarketWatch
all 58 news articles

CPI Financial

AIG sells wealth management unit to Abu Dhabi group
International Herald Tribune, France - 13 hours ago
NEW YORK: American International Group, the troubled insurance giant, said Monday that it had agreed to sell its wealth management provider AIG Private Bank ...
AIG Sheds A Private Bank Forbes
UPDATE 1-AIG to sell AIG Private Bank to UAE's Aabar Reuters
AIG to Sell Private Bank to Aabar Wall Street Journal
Trade Arabia - Reuters
all 174 news articles

Updated Information Regarding Auction Preferred Securities Market ...
MarketWatch - 4 hours ago
BOSTON, Dec 01, 2008 (BUSINESS WIRE) -- MFS Investment Management(R) (MFS) today announced the availability of information on the results of the weekly ...

Lincoln Financial Group Announces New Senior Management Committee ...
International Business Times, NY - 5 hours ago
She will also serve as amember of the firm's Senior Management Committee. Bettinger-Buckingham joins Lincoln Financial with more than 20 years ofexperience ...

Gideon Technologies CEO To Give Unified Compliance Management ...
MarketWatch - 7 hours ago
Unified Compliance Management simplifies this complex problem. "The combination of a holistic centralized view of the network, unified and continuous ...

Research and Markets: Training Management Maturity Model: A ...
MarketWatch - 9 hours ago
How effective is your current training management system? What do you need to do to improve it? Find out with this best practice model and set of assessment ...
Research and Markets: Fundamentals of Quality Control and ... MarketWatch
all 12 news articles

Resources