To Record or Not To Record

I will be honest. I am addicted to music recording. I love moving faders, adjusting levels, panning, reverberating, sequencing, you name it. I especially love all that software, and the colorful ways that they show the music as a waveform. It is just cool.

And I'm not the only one. My cousin has just become hooked as well, and all around the globe many many songwriters are falling prey to the "Call of the Cubase." After all, what once upon a time could break the bank, is now easily accessible on our desktops. Every songwriter can record his/her songs for a pittance. So is this a good thing? And should we all be doing it?

On the surface, it's a no-brainer. Well, why not record? It stimulates creativity. It liberates more music from the brains of its creators. It puts more pleasure into the world. And yet, there is a downside or two to consider when you plan to record your stuff, at least at home.

Natural selection was Darwin's theory, and it applies equally to music as well. I'll be honest, I'm not the greatest songwriter. I tend to write stuff that is too long, overly cliched, and requiring the vocal range of Luciano Pavarotti mixed with Paul Robeson. Every so often, though, almost despite my best efforts, I'll crank out a beaut. When that happens, it deserves immediate posteritizing (recording for posterity), but, alas, there is a long line of "I-really-shouldn't-record-this-but-why-not-it's-cheap-to-do-it" material in front of it. Each of those will take a good week of work to arrange, record, overdub, mix, master, remix, remaster and burn. Add to that two days of regret after I've listened to the atrocious thing, you have 9 days. If I had to pay for a studio, I'd only have gone with the winner, and thos eother songs would have thankfully remained mere twinkles in my eye.

That's the first thing to consider. It's not for the betterment of the world to record everything just because you can. With the advent of the home studio, the natural selection process disappeared, and people don't have the same pressure to let their material grow, become refined, and be sure that they are going for the gold before they start laying down tracks. Always ask yourself if you can do better before you start. Don't let the technology cripple creativity with its instant allure.

Now let's say you really have an ace song on your hands. No reason not to record this, you're saying, and you're right. But. Is doing it at home the way to go? The answer is a resounding ... depends. Depends on what gear you have, sure. But even more, it depends on what you are capable of doing with that gear. If the ease with which one can record at home has limited creative quality, it may do the same to sonic quality when the creativity has been truly remarkable. I love those gadgets, but I will admit that I can never seem to get the sound I hear in my head when I write those songs. If I were properly trained, I'm sure I'd have a different take, but I'm not, and how many of us are?

So my compromise has been to have all the fun in the world with the songs I'm not staking my future on, while the keepers get a professional to make sure that I'll get that record deal. I would highly recommend, however, to record your songs at home as a prequel, if you will, to the studio. The benefits are knowing how your song will take to tape on a basic level, as well as seeing any weaknesses in your arrangements. It is a great scratch pad, and then, when you get into the studio, you'll have a great head start.

I hope everyone thrills to this wonderful world of songwriting, and whether your goal is simply to give CDs to your friends and family or to be a megastar (hope we make it), you'll use home studio technology to stimulate creativity, improve your craft and career and have a blast. Happy tunes!

Seth Lutnick is a singer, songwriter and arranger. Visit his website, http://www.getitdone.biz, for more on creating and using a home recording studio, and personal action planning.

Latest News


Metacafe Invites Viewers to Get Their Groove On With New Music Channel
MarketWatch - 3 hours ago
Metacafe's more than 38 million unique monthly viewers(1) are now invited to watch, comment on and share their favorite music videos. ...

Nokia Music Store Italy: More Than 4 Million Songs
MarketWatch - 6 hours ago
has announced the launch in Italy of its new digital music site, Nokia Music Store, which already has a catalogue of more than 4 million songs amongst which ...

New York Times

He Can Bring the Wine and the Music
New York Times, United States - 10 hours ago
By ERIC ASIMOV FOR music and for wine, David Chan says, language has its limitations. He should know. THE RIGHT NOTES David Chan, violinist and Burgundy ...

Music Review | Kirov Orchestra and Chorus Prokofiev Did Relish a ...
New York Times, United States - 10 hours ago
By JAMES R. OESTREICH It’s too bad, as Harlow Robinson points out in program notes, that Prokofiev never got around to reshaping his music for the two-part ...

Canada.com

Music Review: Chinese Democracy
Entertainment Weekly - 2 hours ago
This is unapologetically huge music, not fit for tiny iPod earbuds. At times it's possible to hear the world-changing CD that Rose — whose banshee howl ...
Axl Rose's Most Amazing MTV Moments, In Bigger Than The Sound MTV.com
Official UK Chinese Democracy premiere announced MusicRadar.com - The place for music makers
'Chinese Democracy' review: Ancient Chinese secret, huh? Hilton Head Island Packet
Idolator - MSNBC
all 109 news articles

paidContent.org - Gaming Roundup: NatGeo; Music Mogul; Square Enix ...
Washington Post, United States - 7 hours ago
?Music-focused virtual world to launch in February : Is there room for another virtual world?and a music-focused one at that? The founders of Music Mogul ...

Product Reviews

Microsoft slashes prices of several Zune music players
Seattle Post Intelligencer - 13 hours ago
By JOSEPH TARTAKOFF Microsoft slashed the prices of several of its Zune music players Tuesday, hoping to drive holiday sales despite the weak economic ...
Microsoft Hopes Price Cuts Will Help Zune in the Holiday Season Profy
all 17 news articles

Telegraph.co.uk

Sleater-Kinney's guitarist tries out Wii Music.
Slate - 4 hours ago
That's what I thought of the first time I played Nintendo's new game Wii Music. Unlike Rock Band and Guitar Hero, where the fun is derived from living ...
"BANDthology-This Game Rocks!" MarketWatch
Wii Music fails to find an audience at launch Ars Technica
Wii Music video game review Telegraph.co.uk
Blabbermouth.net - Softpedia
all 31 news articles

ABC News

A Little Bit of Country Music Goes a Long Way for Nontraditional ...
ABC News - 17 hours ago
By IMAEYEN IBANGA Country music has given birth to some of the nation's best songs, artists and has helped give birth to rock-'n'-roll. ...
Country Music Finds New Star In Darius Rucker NPR
all 2 news articles

Ultimate Ears Launches First Earphones with Top-Fire Speaker Design
MarketWatch - 7 hours ago
Ideal for a wide range of music genres, the Super.Fi 5 and Super.Fi 5vi earphones are the first products on the market with a top-fire-armature speaker ...

Resources