Is Vitamin E Lethal?
Recently the news carried the story that a researcher had discovered that taking vitamin E at a level of 400IU or more increases the risk of death. (Jan 2005, Annals of Internal Medicine) I was immediately suspicious because I have studied the scientific literature on vitamin E for over two decades and have come to the exact opposite conclusion. Hundreds of studies have shown the beneficial effects of vitamin E on numerous modern diseases including cancer, heart disease, Alzheimer's, claudication, arthritis, fibrocystic breast disease, epilepsy, infertility, intelligence?you name it. This evidence comes from carefully controlled clinical trials and meta-nalyses and is published in peer-reviewed publications. So what gives with this new "scoop?" Why did it receive the headlines while all the other studies aren't?
Actually this new information is not new at all. The researcher merely investigated mortality statistics from existing studies and came to a conclusion that people should not take 400IUs of vitamin E (exactly what I have been taking for years and recommending to others) or they may die. In effect he wrote an editorial on other people's work. That is not science.
Although the writer conceded his conclusions may only apply to those who are already seriously ill and not to healthy people, that is the only balance given in the article. He examined 19 different vitamin E studies performed by others including almost 140,000 people. Surely it would seem statistical meaning would emerge out of that. But as science (and life) always goes, the truth is in the details?details too often left out.
For example in one of the 19 studies, large doses of zinc were also given and this can create a copper deficiency which can lead to heart and other diseases. Although a copper supplement was given, it was in the form of cupric oxide, which is poorly absorbed in the gut.
In another of the studies the group being given the vitamin E were much sicker to begin with, including larger numbers of smokers and higher numbers of those with coronary artery disease and high blood pressure. Of course there will be greater mortality in such a group, but it would have nothing to do with the vitamin E they were taking.
Another study was skewed by the fact that participants were also taking a synthetic form of beta-carotene, which has been linked to increased lung cancer and liver damage. You can't give vitamin E and synthetic beta-carotene to a group and blame mortality on vitamin E!
Finally, not one of the studies used the natural form of vitamin E. Vitamin E is a mixture of tocopherols: alpha, beta, gamma and delta. But only alpha- tocopheral was used. Not only that, but the synthetic isomeric form, D, L-alpha tocopherol was used in many of the studies. Natural vitamin E exists in only the D isomeric form. The synthetic L form is not produced in nature and may even interfere with the benefits of the natural D form.
The gamma-tocopherol has many proven life-lengthening and disease preventing benefits but when high levels of alpha-tocopherol are consumed these benefits may be cancelled by a kind of biochemical interference. Therefore, whatever gamma-tocopherol was being consumed in the diet may have been cancelled out by the supplements in the study.
When one is done looking at the details behind the headlines there remains no basis for suggesting that high levels of natural vitamin E are dangerous, but rather, when considering the entire body of scientific evidence, there is significant reason for believing exactly the opposite! So much for headlines.
Perhaps more important than the misleading nature of the story is the reason why it would receive top billing. News organizations seem to be fiendishly rubbing their hands together just waiting for any little tidbit that could debunk the value of supplements or a natural approach to health. (They receive huge advertising dollars from the pharmaceutical and other medical industries.) Of course the medical community is right there ready to pile on as well. They have a vested interest in maintaining the popular mindset that disease is just one of those things that happen, that people are victims of disease, and doctors are needed for repair. The notion that supplements, food, and lifestyle can prevent or cure disease threatens their grip and profitability.
Never mind that modern health care is the greatest threat to life and health, killing more people than any other cause. (Wysong e-Health Letter: June 19, 2002) That's not worthy of news, but scaring people away from supplements based upon a flawed study is. We do not live in a rational world.
Is vitamin E supplementation necessary? No, not if you are eating a varied diet of raw, organic, natural foods, living out of doors, exercising daily and are not subject to any workplace or other environmental pollutants. If that is not how you are living, then 400IU of a natural vitamin E tocopherol mix is a very good idea. It is logical since it replaces what would be present in a natural raw diet and helps offset modern toxins, pollutants and stresses. It is also supported by a mountain of good scientific research.
Dr. Wysong is a former veterinary clinician and surgeon, college instructor in human anatomy, physiology and the origin of life, inventor of numerous medical, surgical, nutritional, athletic and fitness products and devices, research director for the present company by his name and founder of the philanthropic Wysong Institute. He is author of The Creation-Evolution Controversy now in its eleventh printing, a new two volume set on philosophy for living, several books on nutrition, prevention and health for people and animals and over 15 years of monthly health newsletters. He may be contacted at Wysong@Wysong.net and a free subscription to his e-Health Letter is available at http://www.wysong.net
Latest News
 TopNews United States | Fish Oil Supplements can Possibly Reduce the Risk of Diabetes TopNews United States Omega-3 fatty acids are found to be in abundance in fish oil supplements. Researchers at the University of California, San Diego, in a study which was ... Omega-3 Fatty Acids May Reduce Risk Of Insulin Resistance, Inflammation Omega-3 fatty acids can have a downside too |
Research and Markets: This Essential 2010 Edition of Nutritional Supplements ... Trading Markets (press release) Report covers global industry size, segmentation by products such as: vitamins and dietary supplements, Pediatric nutrition, sports nutrition, ... Nutritional Supplements Market to Exceed $13 Billion in 2014 |
NIH funds research on supplements Chicago Tribune (blog) Women are increasingly turning to supplements such as dong quai, black cohosh and licorice root to help relieve menopausal symptoms, including hot flashes ... UIC to study whether botanicals can ease menopause Mizzou gets NIH funding for one of 5 Botanical Research Centers |
Mouse Study May Help Explain Fish Oil's Benefits BusinessWeek Fish oil supplements that contain high levels of omega-3 fatty acids are one of the most popular dietary supplements in the United States. ... Omega-3 fatty acids helps in fight against diabetes The secret to fish oil's anti-inflammatory properties Scientists Know More About Why Fish Oil Reduces Inflammation |
 KOMO News | Officials can't pinpoint ailment's cause ESPN The enzyme creatine kinase is released by muscles when they are injured and is not to be confused with the creatine supplement. ... Heat, Dehydration Factors In McMinnville Injuries Probe Reveals Factors Behind McMinnville Football Illnesses Ore. team can't find cause of H.S. player ailments |
Vita-Tech Donates Supplements to Africa Natural Products Industry Insider Vita-Tech, a contract manufacturer and private label producer of dietary supplements and nutraceuticals, made a similar donation last year. Vita-Tech International Donates Nutritional Products in Africa |
In Weight-Loss Struggle, Americans Are Leery Of Pills NPR (blog) We asked the folks at Thomson Reuters to help us gauge public opinion on diet drugs and supplements. In early August, they talked with more than 3000 people ... |
Nutrition Quiz: Supplements to avoid Bellingham Herald Nutritional supplements are a $26 billion-a-year industry, but there is no Food and Drug Administration oversight. ... |
Breastfeeding HIV-positive women should not receive vitamin A supplements ... Los Angeles Times HIV-positive women who are breastfeeding should not be given vitamin A supplements because it increases the risk of transmitting the AIDS virus to their ... Vitamin supplements may increase risks for pregnant women with HIV Vitamin A supplements linked to high HIV levels in breast milk12 hours ago |
FTC Cracks Down on Acai Supplements, Cites Rachael Ray and Oprah Wall Street Journal (blog) We hate to break it to you, but acai berry supplements are not going to make you drop 10 to 25 pounds in a month. ... FTC halts sales of weight-loss, colon-cleansing Internet sales company FTC: Supplement marketer scammed consumers out of $30 million last year FTC Cracks Down On Acai Berry Supplements |
Resources
-
One word, WOW! Lose weight guaranteed!
Free information on weight loss, diet, fitness, Supplements, and support for successful weight loss!
-
Reduce Cellulite Reduction Cellulite Cream Solution
Free information on weight loss, diet, fitness, Supplements, and support for successful weight loss!
-
Quick and Easy Weight Loss Secrets!
weight loss program, best weight loss program, weight loss guide, how to lose weight, weight loss success, successful weight loss, weight loss plans, weight loss facts, weight loss diets, weight loss
-
VitalityHouse, find out how your immune system can beat flus, colds, and fevers before they start.
Stop low backpain hip pain, neck pain, carpal tunnel syndrome, sciatica and other joint pains; fight stress, headaches, and fatigue; overcome arthritis, and other chronic pain conditions; energy and strength with no expensive Supplements, no pharmaceutica
-
Gain 6lbs of muscle in 15 days
Bodybuilding with or without steroids, Training & Nutrition, Supplements for bodybuilding, Reviews, Steroid Information